Daniel Knighton/Getty Images
- A controversial bill in the Florida legislature would ban discussions around gender and sex in classrooms.
- Critics say the legislation uses “parental rights” as an excuse to marginalize LGBTQ people.
- Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis signaled his support for the bill earlier this week.
President Joe Biden last week made a rare executive move in denouncing a proposed Florida bill making its way through the state legislature.
The partner pieces of legislation have yet to be voted on by the Florida House of Representatives or Senate — though both bodies’ education committees have advanced the bills — making Biden’s public input even more noteworthy.
The legislation, dubbed the “Parental Rights in Education” bill, argues for more parental control in children’s public school education. The measures would allow parents to sue school districts that defy the legislation.
But a brief provision included in both HB 1577 and SB 1834 has catapulted the bills to national attention, as Florida continues to cement itself as the epicenter of the growing battle over parent involvement in education matters.
Dubbed the “Don’t Say Gay” bill by its opponents, the legislation would ban the discussion of sexual orientation and gender identity in Florida primary classrooms — a reality that activists say would further marginalize LGBTQ students.
In his Tuesday statement, Biden called the bills “hateful” and pledged to “continue to fight” for queer students’ protections and safety.
Several additional public figures, as well as advocacy organizations, have spoken out against the legislation in recent weeks. But proponents of the bill swear the measures are meant to protect young children.
What exactly would this bill do?
The answer is not entirely clear. The 30-word measure that has sparked the most debate is written in notably vague language.
“A school district may not encourage classroom discussion about sexual orientation or gender identity in primary grade levels or in a manner that is not age-appropriate or developmentally appropriate for students,” the bills say.
The 4-page text, however, fails to define or explain what language around those topics would be considered “age-appropriate” or “developmentally appropriate.”
The bill’s sponsors, Rep. Joe Harding and Sen. Dennis Baxley have said the provision is a stop-gap on school districts implementing curriculum that would educate children about gender and sexual orientation before they are mature enough to understand it, according to The Tampa Bay Times.
But while the bill and its supporters stipulate that the provision explicitly applies to primary levels, which include grades up to 3rd, opponents worry the ambiguous language could mean the measures end up being applied to older students as well, the outlet reported.
The bill’s sponsors have said that informal conversations between students and teachers about gender and sexuality, as well as school clubs, would not be prohibited under the legislation.
But LGBTQ rights groups and advocates say the legislation is posing a solution to a problem that does not exist. Nadine Smith, executive director of Equality Florida, told The Times that no “developmentally inappropriate” curriculum concerning sexual orientation or gender identity is even being taught in primary classrooms.
The legislation would also allow parents to sue school districts that don’t alert them to “critical decisions affecting a student’s mental, emotional, or physical health or well-being.”
During a committee hearing on Tuesday, Baxley confirmed that conversations surrounding a child’s sexuality or gender-identity are included under that umbrella, meaning the legislation would bar school districts from maintaining confidentiality policies that prohibit educators from divulging information about a child’s sexual orientation or gender identity to their parents.
The bill does allow for school districts to withhold such information from parents if a “reasonably prudent person” would determine that disclosure could lead to “abuse, abandonment, or neglect.”
(AP Photo/David Zalubowski, File)
This legislation further cements Florida as a hotspot for ‘parental rights’
In recent years, Florida has become a hotspot for the burgeoning conservative fixation on parental rights in education. Under the helm of Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis, the state has proposed and passed several measures geared toward strengthening parents’ input in the classroom.
The national battle over pandemic masking in schools got its publicized start in Florida, when DeSantis banned mask mandates in public schools just days before the start of the 2021/2022 school year. When school districts and educators fought back, the governor threatened to withhold paychecks from school officials who flouted the executive order.
Then, earlier this year, DeSantis formally asked the state legislature to pass a bill that would allow parents to sue school districts that teach critical race theory.
And last year, DeSantis signed the “Parents’ Bill of Rights” into law, which forbids government agencies from impeding parents’ rights to “direct the upbringing, education, health care, and mental health” of their children.
The “Parental Rights in Education” bills fall in line with the state’s previous efforts to legislate the classroom, albeit, advancing parental power around a new topic.
Will this bill become law?
On Tuesday, February 8, the state Senate version of the bill passed the education committee along party lines, nearly one month after the state House version did the same.
The state House version has since been referred to the Judiciary Committee while the state Senate bill makes its way through appropriations.
Republicans control both chambers of the Florida Legislature. If signed into law, the bill would go into effect in July.
Last week, DeSantis signaled his support for the legislation, telling reporters that it was “entirely inappropriate” for teachers to be talking about topics like sexual orientation and gender identity with students.
“Schools need to be teaching kids to read, to write,” DeSantis said during a press conference. “They need to teach them science, history.”
The governor cited alleged examples of teachers telling students not to worry about “picking their gender” and suggested educators were hiding classroom material from parents.
While the governor didn’t go so far as to promise he would sign the bill into law, his recent statements along with his proven track record regarding issues of parental rights suggest DeSantis’ ultimate support for the controversial bill.
Powered by WPeMatico
